AND YOU CAN BE THE CAT
Hazel Hutchins
Reviewed by Marion Scott
Volume 20 Number 3
Hutchins and Ohi have collaborated on a picture-book with a highly appealing storyline: Norman, older sister Leanna, and Leanna's friend Neil play make-believe, but Norman, the youngest, always gels a secondary role - the cat. When he tires of this and misbehaves, Norman is banished. However, when left to his own devices, he begins a now game that is so appealing that Leanna and Neil not only join in but let Norman choose his own part. This is Hutchins' best writing yet. She has deftly observed both big-sister - little-brother dynamics and the world of imaginative play. Both are portrayed with a sure and humorous touch, and the telling is nicely shaped and paced. Unfortunately, the illustrations are undistinguished. Ohi uses a simple, childlike style, but the result is mostly bland. Colour choices are dull, and the children lack distinctiveness and expression. With the exception of one or two moments, background detail tends to overwhelm and the artwork fails to convoy the underlying humour. The end result is certainly acceptable and will undoubtedly strike a chord with three-to seven-year-olds. The disappointment lies in the fact that there was potential for something better. This title is worth considering and would be a popular addition to both core and browsing collections. Both Hutchins and Ohi are familiar names, each with several children's books to her credit. They have also worked together previously. Past collaborations include Nicholas at the library and Norman's Snowball. Marion Scott, Toronto Public Library, Toronto, Ont.
|
1971-1979 | 1980-1985 | 1986-1990 | 1991-1995
The materials in this archive are copyright © The Manitoba Library Association. Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without permission Copyright information for reviewers
Digital Collections / Collections Numérisees