________________
CM . . . .
Volume V Number 13 . . . . February 26, 1999
The Blue Jackal and The Foolish Lion are two stories from Book I
of the Panchatantra, a collection of fables from India written in
Sanskrit about 200 BC, with authorship attributed to Pandit Vishnu Sharma.
This kit, containing both oral and written versions of these stories, is
intended to help children learn to read. It is suggested in the accompanying
guide that children should begin by listening to the stories and enjoying the
illustrations. Then, after a few hearings, the child should attempt to follow
the script while listening to the story.
While notes on the book covers recommend these stories for children ages 3 to
7, they could certainly be enjoyed by older students and also be used for a
middle school unit on fables or folk tales. The reading level is about grade 7;
therefore, only very advanced seven-year olds would actually be able to learn
to read the stories on their own.
The audio tapes are very well done. The voices of narrator Karadi the bear and
the other animals are done by professional Indian actors. Use of sound effects
and the musical soundtrack are excellent. I wonder, however, why the words of
the songs were not incorporated into the text so that the children could follow
them and perhaps learn to sing them. The song lyrics are included at the end of
the stories and in cursive writing as opposed to print. The music is not given.
The written versions of the stories are beautifully illustrated with colourful,
very detailed and often humorous pictures. For example, Karadi, the elderly
bear narrator, is pictured in The Blue Jackal with white goatee and
bushy eyebrows, leaning on a cane while wearing fluffy blue bedroom slippers.
The stories are similar in style to Aesop's fables and other traditional animal
tales used to educate and amuse children. The following excerpt from The
Foolish Lion tells how Chatura the hare got rid of the cruel lion Budhu by
tricking him into thinking that another lion lived at the bottom of the well.
"Come out you coward," Budhu yelled.
Coward...coward...the well echoed back.
"He dares call me a coward. I will show him,"
thought Budhu. With an intention to kill the
other lion, Budhu, with all his strength and
fury, dived into the well. As he fell screaming
to the bottom, a deathly scream echoed back.
It was the most frightening sound that the
jungle had ever heard. Budhu crashed to the
bottom of the well and died instantly. (Page 21)
One minor criticism is that, in several places towards the end of The
Foolish Lion, quotations are not separated from the name of the speaker
with commas as they should be.
Highly recommended.
Irene Gordon of Headingley, MB., is a free-lance writer and former
teacher-librarian who spent 14 years working in a junior high school library.
To comment on this
title or this review, send mail to cm@umanitoba.ca.
Copyright © the Manitoba Library Association.
Reproduction for personal use is permitted only if this copyright notice
is maintained. Any other reproduction is prohibited without
permission.
Published by
TABLE OF CONTENTS FOR THIS ISSUE - FEBRUARY 26, 1999.
AUTHORS |
TITLES |
MEDIA REVIEWS |
PROFILES |
BACK ISSUES |
SEARCH |
CMARCHIVE |
HOME
|